Phnom Penh, serving Cambodia and the region

Nitrogen & blowers

Roots, Screw or Turbo Blower? Choosing Low-Pressure Air for Aeration and Conveying

Roots vs screw vs turbo blower: how flow range, pressure, turndown and duty decide the right low-pressure air for wastewater aeration and pneumatic conveying.

Nexus Turnkey Engineering Team6 min read

Choose by duty profile, not by nameplate

Roots, screw and turbo blowers all deliver large volumes of low-pressure air. The right one depends on your flow range, discharge pressure, how much demand varies and how many hours the machine runs. In short: a Roots blower is simple, tough and suits conveying and smaller or intermittent duties. A screw blower holds efficiency across a wide speed range and suits variable duty at the higher end of blower pressures. A turbo blower is compact, quiet and oil-free, and suits large, steady aeration loads that stay near its design point.

Many plants end up with a mix, sized so each machine runs where it is most efficient. This article explains how each works and how to compare them fairly. It sits alongside our industrial compressed air guide, which covers the high-pressure side.

How the three technologies differ

Roots (rotary lobe): positive displacement, no internal compression

Two lobed rotors turn in opposite directions without touching, trapping pockets of air and carrying them from inlet to outlet. There is no compression inside the machine. The air is compressed when the pocket opens to the higher-pressure discharge. That makes Roots blowers simple and tolerant, but less efficient as discharge pressure rises, and noisy, with pressure pulsation that needs silencing.

Flow is roughly proportional to speed, so a VSD gives straightforward flow control over a wide range.

Screw blower: positive displacement with internal compression

A screw blower uses two helical rotors, like a compressor airend, built for low pressure. Air is compressed progressively inside the machine, which avoids much of the loss of the Roots principle at higher blower pressures. With a VSD, a screw blower holds efficiency across a wide turndown. It suits aeration with varying demand and conveying duties.

Turbo blower: dynamic compression at high speed

A turbo blower spins an impeller at very high speed, typically on magnetic or air-foil bearings with no oil in the air path, driven by a high-speed motor and drive. It is compact and quiet. Efficiency is high near its design point.

As a dynamic machine, it has two limits. Turndown is narrower than for positive displacement blowers. And at low flow against high pressure it can reach surge, an unstable flow reversal that the controls must prevent. Pressure capability also falls as inlet air gets hotter.

Side-channel blowers

For small flows at low pressure, such as vacuum lifting, small aeration tanks or drying, a side-channel blower is often the simplest choice. It is outside the main comparison below.

The comparison at a glance

RootsScrewTurbo
PrinciplePositive displacement, no internal compressionPositive displacement, internal compressionDynamic, high-speed impeller
EfficiencyGood at low pressure, falls as pressure risesGood across a wide speed rangeHigh near design point
TurndownWide with VSDWide with VSDNarrower; must avoid surge
Tolerance of varying pressureHighHighLower
Typical fitConveying, small and intermittent aerationVariable aeration, conveyingLarge, steady aeration

A blower that runs most of its hours far from its best efficiency point is the wrong blower, whatever its peak rating says.

Aeration: the biggest blower load in many plants

In activated-sludge wastewater treatment, blowers supply the oxygen the bacteria need. The Water Environment Federation’s manual on energy conservation in water and wastewater facilities puts aeration at roughly 25 to 60 percent of total energy use at wastewater treatment plants. That makes blower selection and control one of the largest energy decisions in the plant.

Aeration demand changes through the day with the incoming load. The best systems control blowers from dissolved oxygen measurements, run a combination of machines so each stays near its efficient range, and keep N+1 redundancy so a single failure does not stop treatment. See our water and wastewater page.

Pneumatic conveying: stable pressure under changing load

Dilute-phase conveying of cement, flour, rice and feed needs a steady airflow against a pressure that rises and falls with the product load in the line. Positive displacement machines suit that well, because their flow stays close to constant as pressure changes. Roots blowers are the traditional choice; screw blowers are an alternative where efficiency and noise matter. See our cement and building materials and agro-processing pages.

Tropical conditions change the sizing

Two other local factors matter. Dusty air needs good inlet filtration, because dust wears rotors and impellers and loads coolers. And high-speed drives need clean, stable power, so protection against voltage dips and harmonics belongs in the electrical design.

Controls make the selection work

The best blower selection can still waste energy with poor controls. In aeration, dissolved oxygen sensors in each zone tell the control system how much air is needed. Air control valves distribute it, and the blowers respond. A common strategy keeps the most-open valve near fully open, so the blowers supply only the pressure the system actually needs rather than a fixed, conservative set-point.

With several blowers, a sequencer decides which machines run and at what speed, so each one stays in its efficient range and run hours are shared. Mixed fleets, such as a turbo for the steady base and a screw or Roots machine with a VSD for peaks and low-flow periods, need controls that understand each machine’s limits, including the surge line of the turbo. A PLC handles this logic locally, and a SCADA system makes the energy per unit of air visible.

Maintenance differs by technology

Roots and screw blowers have oil-lubricated gears and bearings, and many use belt drives, so oil changes, belt tension and bearing checks are routine. Turbo blowers on magnetic or air-foil bearings have few wearing parts, but their inlet filters, drive cooling and electronics need regular attention. Whatever the type, inlet filters matter in dusty plants, and blocked filters reduce flow and raise power.

How to compare quotes fairly

Blower quotes are easy to make look good. The fair basis is wire-to-air performance: total electrical input power, including motor, drive, cooling and ancillaries, against air delivered at the outlet. ASME PTC 13 is a performance test code written for exactly that comparison, covering both positive displacement and dynamic blower packages.

  • Flow at minimum, average and maximum demand, in m³/h or Nm³/h
  • Discharge pressure at each duty point, including diffuser submergence, line and filter losses
  • Inlet temperature, humidity and altitude for the worst case
  • Running hours at each duty point over a typical day
  • Wire-to-air power at each duty point, not just at full load
  • Turndown range and how surge is prevented, for dynamic machines
  • Noise limits and enclosure requirements
  • Redundancy: number of duty and standby units

Flow figures arrive in m³/h, m³/min and cfm. Our unit converter puts them on one basis, and the system selector gives a first view of which technology suits your duty. If you are comparing blowers on energy, the same logic applies as for compressors; see fixed speed vs VSD vs PM-VSD compressors. Savings are project-specific. We measure them against a baseline and verify them after implementation; we don’t promise a blanket percentage.

Match the machine to the hours

Start with the demand profile, then choose the machines that cover it efficiently, with redundancy and controls that keep each one in its best range. We supply Roots, screw, turbo and side-channel blowers in the Nexus range, with capacities selected to your load (ask for a datasheet). See our blowers page for the range, and talk to us about the controls and pipework that make them work as one system.

Nexus Turnkey Engineering Team

Written and reviewed by the engineers who design, install and maintain industrial air systems for Nexus Turnkey in Cambodia. Questions about this article? Ask us directly.

FAQ

Questions engineers ask us

Which blower is most efficient?

It depends on the operating point. Turbo blowers tend to be efficient near their design point with steady demand. Screw blowers hold efficiency well across a wide speed range. Roots blowers are simple and tough but less efficient as pressure rises. Compare candidates by measured wire-to-air power at your actual duty points, for example to ASME PTC 13.

Can a turbo blower handle very variable demand?

Within limits. Turbo blowers have a narrower turndown than positive displacement machines and must stay clear of surge. For very variable demand, a mix of machines, or a screw or Roots blower with a variable speed drive for the low-flow periods, is often a better fit.

Is a blower the same as a compressor?

Both move air, but blowers work at much lower pressure ratios. They deliver large volumes of air at low pressure, which suits aeration, conveying and combustion air. Using a compressor for these duties and throttling it down wastes energy.

Does hot weather affect blowers?

Yes. Hot air is less dense, so a blower moves less mass of air, and less oxygen, per cubic metre. Dynamic machines such as turbo blowers are particularly sensitive to inlet temperature. Size for the hottest expected inlet conditions.

Next step

Turn this into a plan for your plant.

Send us your situation and an engineer will reply with the questions that matter and a sensible next step.

Start typing to search